Carrying scarf or carrier? It is up to you!: To each his camp. There is no shortage of supporters of one or the other porting method. Nor are the arguments, against a background of controversy. We make the point, as objective as possible!

Carrying scarf or carrier? It is up to you!
Carrying scarf or carrier? It is up to you!

The importance of bringing the newborn child against each other is no longer to be demonstrated. “  Carrying a baby is a necessary care  ,” says psychologist and psychoanalyst Sophie Marinopoulos. The warmth of contact creates and maintains the early mother-child bond. To feel the smell of her mother, to be lulled by her steps gives the newborn a sense of security that he needs to leave later to discover the world. “We do not carry a baby against ourselves because we can not do it alone,” she says. It is also taken by thought and feelings. The great English psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott called this the “holding.” Remain the method! The arms are the most obvious and the best nest possible.

We recommend reading the article: Fruit Juices in Baby Diet

The classic baby carrier: practical

It is the most common type of porterage in our country and the Nordic countries. It even develops at high-speed V in China! Initially, in the 1960s, the baby carrier looked more like a “strapless bag” or a kangaroo pocket. In recent years, the models have continued to be sophisticated and are the subject of extensive research with psychomotor imans, physiotherapists and pediatricians to optimize their ergonomics and to respect the morphology of the toddler.

The principle: they are simple to use, once the first adjustment of the shoulder straps and the ventral belt made to your measurements. The newborn (from 3.5 kg) is turned face to face to protect it from the environment and monitor it. To install it facing the road, it is necessary to wait four months, that it is tonic and holds the head and the bust straight. One can place the harness on or under a coat, and many current models allow to keep it on itself, while just removing the child part with the baby in it. Without disturbing him.

Plus: for the baby, the head restraint (made mandatory by the European standard) is important the very first months, to support its head nodding and avoid the effect of “blow of the rabbit.” The height and depth of the seat are adjusted precisely. Finally, it provides good back support. For the wearer, the distribution of the child’s weight between the shoulders, back, and hips with straps and a padded lumbar belt avoids the points of tension. It is often high price can be explained by the complexity of its design, as well as the quality of the materials used, such as an Oeko-Tex® labeled name, without heavy metals in dyeing. Provided up to 15 kg,

What he is accused of: the followers of the scarf wear reproach the perfect baby carrier to hang the baby with dangling legs and dangling arms. Some also mention the fact that, sitting on her genitals, little boys can then have fertility problems. Old or low-end items, maybe. On the other hand, the manufacturers of current models claim to study them so that the child is seated on his buttocks, legs placed in a natural way.

Carrying scarf: a way of life

Inspired by the traditional portage techniques used in many African or Asian civilizations, the Portage scarf has appeared in us in recent years, in the wake of the movements of natural mothering. Its use has since grown, and it now joins the circuit of more conventional childcare stores.

The principle: it is a large strip of fabric of several meters (from 3.60 m to nearly 6 m according to the mode of knotting) that is scholarly around to accommodate the all- small. The fabric is made of cotton or bamboo to be soft in contact with the skin, and both resistant and supple.

The most: swaddled in this way, the newborn is a body with his mother, glued on her belly, as an extension of their fusion. In the first weeks, the scarf allows different positions of the baby depending on the time of day: straight ahead, semi-elongated to breastfeed discreetly, open to the world … Another benefit noticed by Anne Deblois **: It is worn all against the body of an adult, it benefits from the system of thermoregulation of the wearer, in winter as in summer. ”

What he is criticized for less quick to install on himself than a baby carrier, the carrying scarf is not necessarily visible to tie with the right technique according to the age of the child, to ensure a physiological position safely. Attending workshop classes may be required. Unlike the carrier, the scarf has almost no age limit. Only the weight is bearable by the wearer … hence the temptation of some young parents to wear it in a still fusional way at the age when the child must learn to walk on his own and become autonomous. However, this is a question more about lifestyle and educational than technical! On the polemic side,

The “physiological” baby carrier: the third way (between the two)

For those who hesitate between these two portages, the solution is perhaps on the side of baby carriers called “physiological” or “ergonomic,” developed by the brands following the leader Ergobaby.

The principle: halfway between the scarf and the traditional baby carrier, it is inspired by the carrying style of Thai children, with a large pocket with a full seat and straps.

Plus: it does not have a long piece of fabric to tie, eliminating the risk of improper installation. It closes either by a single loop or by the fast node. The pocket that contains the child ensures an “M” position, knees slightly higher than the hips, and the back is rounded. On the wearer’s side, the lap belt is usually padded to ensure good support.

What is criticized: it is still a lack of perspective to decide on the benefits of the position of the baby about its morphology. It remains the fact that it is not advisable to use it as is with an infant for four months. It would float there without good behavior, especially in the legs. The parade: some models offer a kind of removable cushion reducing.

You may also be interested in: Baby Gear Buying Guide: best baby carrier for breastfeeding